Article, Thursday, May 22, 2003
Compares Alienware Area 51 to Dell Dimension XPS
Area 51
Maker: Alienware (www.alienware.com)
Processor: Intel 3.06 GHz with 800 MHz front-side bus
Graphics Card: ATI Radeon 9800 Pro or Nvidia GeForce FX 5800
Memory: 1 gigabyte
Price: $3,000 - $3,100 depending on configuration
Dimension XPS
Maker: Dell (www.dell.com)
Processor: Intel 3.06 GHz with 800 MHz front-side bus
Graphics Card: ATI Radeon 9800 Pro
Memory: 1 gigabyte
Price: $3,200 with 20-inch monitor
Price Check, July 3, 2003:
(Now available: NVIDIA GeForce FX 5900 Ultra w/ 256MB; Intel 3.2 GHz & 800
MHz FSB)
(Price Updates from Sept. 2003 in blue)
(Price Update from April 2004 in red)
Summary, April 2004 - Dell has clearly pulled away in offering a reasonably priced high performance machine.
I matched up the board, memory, feature set, etc. for the Dell 8200 and the Alienware
Area-51(3.0 GHz based system), the 8300 based model comes from Dell for $1,110,while the AlienWare system costs $1,535. Get Dell when they're offering free shipping, and you save another $140 or so over Alienware (for a total of $545; do you really want to pay $545 more just for the AlienWare case?) The big advantage of the AlienWare system is that they give you a lot more slots and drive bays. But do you really need six 3.5" slots?
| Area-51 Extreme (Aurora Extreme) |
$2,710 ($2,575) [$3,210] |
P4*, 3.2GHz 800MHz FSB; 1GB DDR SDRAM; 120GB HD w/
8MB cache; GeForce FX 5900 w/256MB; Audigy2 *or AMD Athlon XP Processor 3200: "Area-51" are Pentium-based, "Aurora" are AMD-based. |
|||||||
| Dell XPS "Ultimate" | $3,080 | P4, 3.0GHz 800MHz FSB; 1GB DDR SDRAM; 200GB HD w/ 8MB cache; ATI Radeon 9800 Pro w/128MB; Audigy2; 4x DVD+RW/+R with CD-RW | with monitor: $3,500 | ||||||
| Area-51 Enthusiast |
|
P4, 3.0GHz 800MHz FSB; 1GB DDR SDRAM; 120GB HD w/ 8MB cache; ATI Radeon 9800 Pro w/128MB; Audigy2 Update, April 2004: the area 51 models are all back to the NVIDIA GeForce FX (5950 Ultra 256MB, 5900 SE 128MB, or 5200 Ultra 128MB) -Optical Drive 1: 16x DVD-ROM ; Optical Dive 2: None -No monitor, No speakers Price Update, video option: NVIDIA GeForce FX 5600 Ultra 128MB 8x AGP w/DVI & S-Video Price Update, Nov. 2003, Dell : from Sept to Nov (2 months) price went UP to $2,580 (+$200) Price Update, April 2004, Dell: now with 3.2GHz processor, |
PRICE COMPARE SYSTEM: Alienware quote id: | ||||||
| Dell
XPS "Cutting Ege" |
|
Dell is $277 more, but you get a "free" CD-RW Drive | |||||||
| price update April 2004: Area 51 Enthusiast base model: $2,034; Options listed above: $1,850 (only $230 reduction since Sept., but $400 reduction since July of last year.) Dell XPS Cutting Edge (options above): $1,750 ($100 less than Area-51), + free shipping See Summary, above. |
|||||||||
| Area-51 Performance | $1,600 |
P4, 2.8GHz 800MHz FSB 512KB Cache , 512MB DDR SDRAM; 80GB
HD w/ 2MB cache; GeForce FX 5200 w/128MB; Audigy 1397 system update April 2002: same price, system now has P4, 3.0GHz 800MHz FSB 512KB Cache ; 512MB DDR PC-3200* SDRAM; 80GB Seagate Serial ATA 8MB Cache; GeForce FX 5200 Ultra 128MB; Audigy 2 *PC-3200 DDR SDRAM operates at an effective rate of 400MHz. |
|||||||
| Dell XPS "Base Model" |
$1,900 | P4, 2.8GHz 800MHz FSB, 512MB DDR SDRAM; 120GB HD w/ ??MB cache; ATI Radeon 9800 Pro w/128MB; CD-RW drive; Audigy2 |
Ace's Hardware seems to prefer the Radeon 9800 Pro slightly over the GeForce
FX 5800 Ultra. "[APRIL 2003]: The Radeon 9800 Pro makes incremental
performance improvements over the Radeon 9700 Pro thanks to its increase core
and memory clockspeeds. With its $399 price tag, the Radeon 9800 Pro is unlikely
to entice current Radeon 9700 or GeForce FX owners, though it should provide
a significant upgrade for GeForce 4 and Radeon 8500 owners. "
"PCI Express is a new Intel bus architecture that doubles the bandwidth of the AGP 8X bus, delivering over 4 GB per second in both upstream and downstream data transfers. Supported in the GeForce PCX GPUs and some versions of the GeForce 6800 GPUs." But don't bother buying a PCI Express card now: you'll have REAL trouble finding any system board that supports them (Intel doesn't have them, so they probably don't exist yet). - April 2004.
| Posted on Thu, May. 22, 2003 | www.MERCURYNEWS.com The San Jose Mercury News |
||
Graphics chips now zap `jaggies'
| |||
my quote: $ 3,200.00 Your quote id is
606468 . Please write it down for future reference.
Similar Dell: $2,800
Price for FarCry
contest:
Case: Alienware ATX Case (420-Watt PS)
Processor: AMD Athlon 64 FX-51 Processor
.. (FX-51 no longer available: choices are Athlon 64 3200+, Athlon 64 3400+,
or Athlon 64 FX-53)
.. (FX-53 is 2.4GHz, 1600MHz system bus; The 3400 is 2.2 GHz;
the 3200 is 2.0 GHz)
.. the A 64 3200+ shows generally better performance than the P4 3.2 GHz
Motherboard: ASUS SK8N - NVIDIA® nForce3 Pro 150 Motherboard
Memory: 1GB Registered ECC DDR SDRAM PC-3200
Hard Drive: 80GB 7200RPM Ultra ATA100 Hard Drive
Video Card: Alienware Extreme Edition NVIDIA GeForce FX 5950 Ultra
256MB DDR [6800 Ultra 256MB +$543]
Optical Drive One: 16x/48x DVD-ROM - Black
Optical Drive Two: 52x/32x/52x CD-RW - Black
Video Cooling: AlienIce Video Cooling System
Operating System: Microsoft® Windows® XP Home Edition
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
performance model has ASUS K8V Deluxe - VIA K8T800 Motherboard
"the new Pentium 4 with 2 MB L3 cache an Emergency Edition chip"
Athlon 64 FX boards allow you to use up four 2 GB DIMMS (very expensive) for
a total of 8 GB of RAM.
So the Athlon 64 FX is a true 64 bit workstation CPU: ECC, 64-bit addressing,
and a platform that can break the 4 GB memory limit.
[FX-53 based systems currently used DDR SDRAM PC-3200]
The 754-pin Athlon 64 3200+, a 2 GHz CPU, is much less demanding: it works
with "normal" unbuffered DDR400.